Wednesday, October 30, 2024
3 Things You Can Do to Stay Relevant as AI Alters the Workplace
While a few of the senior executives that I coach are on the cutting edge of AI, most are more focused on staying relevant in this time of massive change.
You may have heard that, “If your job is not replaced by AI, it will likely be replaced by someone more skilled at using AI.” In my coaching sessions with executives, we use this point to brainstorm how they can leverage AI to improve their communication.
Here are three specific opportunities for how you can elevate your communication effectiveness and stay relevant:
1. AI and Enhanced Writing
Gone are the days of simply running spell-checks before sending emails or reports. AI-powered tools like Grammarly and ChatGPT assist in drafting and refining documents, improving clarity and tone. Leveraging these tools can improve your communication, but over-reliance can depersonalize messages.
How to stay relevant:
Improve your writing by leveraging AI at all stages of the writing process, from your outline to brainstorming, to writing.
Then evaluate your writing beyond spell-check by measuring tone and potentially biased language.
Use these tools to boost the efficiency and effectiveness of your writing, while always maintaining your personal voice.
2. AI for Meeting Notes and Summaries
Software tools like Microsoft Teams, Zoom Workplace, and Otter.ai now generate detailed meeting summaries automatically. I just started doing this myself and it is a game-changer! Now I can focus more on real-time communication in meetings and coaching sessions.
Assessing the meeting summary takes just a few minutes and serves to reinforce the key meeting takeaways. And the bonus? Knowing that the meeting is being summarized keeps our conversation more on track.
How to stay relevant:
Download software to summarize your online meetings.
After every important meeting, add five minutes to run through the meeting summary. Edit to ensure the main points and next steps are clearly identified, then forward the summary to appropriate colleagues.
3. Video Analytics
AI-powered video analytics can help with your personal communication effectiveness as well as analysis of team dynamics. With software such as Yoodli.ai, you can upload a video of your formal presentation – whether onstage in front of a big audience or in a virtual meeting. You can evaluate your tone, filler words (“umm…”), pace, intonation, body language, and more.
You can also use AI to monitor and analyze virtual meetings, attention spans, participation levels, and engagement metrics.
How to stay relevant:
Leverage AI to measure the effectiveness of your formal presentations over time.
Use insights from AI to improve meeting facilitation skills, ensuring everyone stays engaged and aligned.
Upskill Your Communication with AI
AI is no longer a distant concept—it’s now embedded in how we interact at work. From chatbots to automated meeting summaries, it is revolutionizing workplace communication both externally with customers and other stakeholders, as well as internally with our colleagues.
Staying relevant means embracing these technologies while honing our human touch. The future of workplace interactions will be a blend of AI-driven tools and human communication.
EXPERT OPINION BY ANDREA WOJNICKI, EXECUTIVE COMMUNICATION COACH AT TALK ABOUT TALK
Tuesday, October 29, 2024
All Those Zoom AI Note-Taking Apps Have Gotten Out of Hand and Are Ruining Meetings
At first, the idea that you could have an AI robot transcribe a Zoom meeting you couldn’t attend seemed amazing. You’d go on with whatever it was you had that was more important than attending the meeting and you’d get an email with a transcript later on. What could be better than that?
Of course, if you’re in the meeting, the whole thing is kind of weird. I was in a meeting recently with around a dozen or so attendees. Except, four of those attendees were just a blank screen that said something like “Fireflies AI” or “Otter.ai.” Those AI robots were listening to everything we said, recording it, and transcribing it, whether anyone else on the call liked it or not.
That means that an entire third of the attendees of that meeting had something more important to do than attend the meeting. I think we can all agree it’s getting out of hand. After all, there’s probably a reason you were invited to the meeting. Presumably, it’s because you have something to offer.
Really, there are three ways these AI note-taking robots are ruining meetings:
Too Easy to Skip
First, and this seems obvious, but it gives people who should be in a meeting too easy of a way out. A thing that seems to be true is that if you avoid a meeting by sending a robot to take notes, you’re more likely to avoid that meeting. I suppose that says something about the fact technology is capable of such a thing, but I think it says a lot more about the way we think about meetings.
To be clear, I think it’s fine for a meeting to be recorded and transcribed. I just think it’s weird that people are sending their AI robot to attend on their behalf so they don’t have to sit through the meeting. As a general rule, if you feel like sending an AI note-taking robot to attend a meeting in your place, you’re pretty much suggesting that the meeting isn’t very important to you at all.
What you’re really saying is “This meeting isn’t important enough to be on my calendar, but I’ll read the summary.”
To be fair, that’s probably true of a lot of meetings. A thing that definitely seems to be true is that Zoom has made it easier for people to schedule meetings, maybe too easy. A lot of Zoom meetings should just be an email or Slack message, but I’m just not sure this is the right solution. I think a much better way to make meetings better is to invite the right people and make sure everyone clearly understands the purpose of the meeting.
An Invasion of Privacy
Second, having multiple transcription robots on a Zoom call creates a weird dynamic. Not only does it create feelings about the people who skipped the meeting and sent the robots in the first place, but it also creates weird feelings about the meeting itself because you know someone who isn’t there is having it recorded and transcribed. It feels like a gross invasion of privacy.
Expectations are Everything
Finally, even if everyone is okay with the fact that someone is recording the meeting, there’s an expectation that if you skip a meeting and have it transcribed, you’re going to actually listen or read it. It seems reasonable that everyone else might just assume you’ll be up to speed. The thing is, I’m not sure that’s a good assumption to make. If the meeting wasn’t important enough to show up in the first place, it’s not a given that it’ll be important enough to read about later.
The lesson here is pretty simple—just because you can, doesn’t mean you should. That actually applies in a lot of areas of our lives, but especially when it comes to meetings. Just because Zoom makes it easier to have a meeting, doesn’t mean you should. And, just because you can send your AI robot to take notes, doesn’t mean it wouldn’t be better for everyone if you show up in person.
EXPERT OPINION BY JASON ATEN, TECH COLUMNIST @JASONATEN
Friday, October 25, 2024
Tech execs ask: Why have product managers when you can just keep using AI?
I’ve known her since she founded her startup while still in college in the late 2000s and built it up to a pretty sizable concern before ultimately winding it down after five years. She made many of the mistakes most first-time entrepreneurs make but also did many things right that most first-time entrepreneurs never do right.
She’s not tech. She knows how to create, innovate, and sell, especially in the consumer market, with all its complexities and shifting priorities.
In other words, she knows what the people want and how to bring it to them.
In the sense of “product” – product science, product development, product management – this is, like, must-have skill number one. At the end of the day, “product” is all about solving a problem at a price that a lot of people are willing to pay.
But while she bounced around in various lead sales and marketing positions for several startups in the time since she shuttered her own business, she had never thought of herself as a “product person.”
“I’ve been doing fractional work around brand and product strategy for the past two years,” she told me. “I’ve recently become interested in moving more toward product in tech.”
Again, she’s not tech. So she wanted some insight into the tech product world. She called me a “product legend.” I said absolutely, but if she used the word “legend” again the meeting was off.
She laughed. I didn’t have the heart to tell her tech product is dying.
Who am I kidding? Of course, I told her that!
Here’s what we talked about.
The product role has evolved again and not in a good way
Look, I’m not only not a product legend, but in my heart of hearts, I don’t really consider myself a “product person,” even though I’ve been a chief product officer for 15 years across three companies.
I just kind of fell into it and now it’s a role of convenience because what I do is hard to explain.
I’m an entrepreneur who has sold companies and an innovator who holds a patent. I know how to get shit done, and I have a background in software development and an education in systems and data. But my top skill is that I know what people want and how to bring it to them.
So that makes me a “product person.” And since I’ve been doing it longer than it’s been a thing, it makes me an OG product person.
Like any OG, I guess, I’m now longing for the good old days. But not like you might think. See, the product role stumbled into existence with the expansion of software from business to consumer, from desktop to Web to mobile, and from corporate-driven to innovation-driven.
Not that software was never that, but in the mid/late 2000s it was becoming a lot more of that very quickly. Someone needed to shepherd all that innovation from the company’s collective brain into the users’ collective hands, almost literally.
As an entrepreneur who knew what the people wanted and who could code, lead, and speak, I fit this role pretty well.
Eff it. I’ll do it.
Product is still being confused with project
From those early days, most corporations outside of the startup world didn’t have a handle on how to make the product role work for them, so the conflation of product management with project management was born.
I’ve been fighting this for almost 20 years.
Both roles are valid and often needed. But while product is about creating the thing, from ideation to use case to upsell, project is about delivering the thing, from requirements to launch.
I don’t mind when these roles overlap. I don’t mind when product management has to absorb project management or even perform it.
What I do mind is that when people who have no sense of innovation, no understanding of customers and markets, and who consistently prioritize timelines above top and bottom lines start thinking they can do the product role.
By the mid/late 2010s, there was an understanding of the difference between the two functions and all the roles, and things were good. Then they weren’t. Now, product management is evolving again into its own form of project management.
About a month ago, I wrote a column called “The Slow, Painful Death Of Agile and Jira,” in which I asked when Agile stopped being an optional methodology and became a religion. The only negative feedback I got – in an overwhelming landslide of positive feedback – was for calling Agile a methodology, thus proving that I didn’t understand it.
I didn’t respond to any of that criticism there, but I will here.
Naw, man. It’s a methodology now. That’s my entire point. Sorry I gave you intellectual credit and didn’t hit you over the head with it.
Ah, I feel so much better now.
Product has its own demons now
It’s not just the crushing misinterpretation of the Agile manifesto or the constant stop-start-stop pace of Scrum or the horrible micromanagement UX of Jira turning product management back into project management. Over the lpast couple of years, it’s become a misinterpretation of the product role itself.
Experimentation is being deemphasized for the sake of an unbending roadmap. Create it. Set it. Forget it.
Innovation is being pushed out in favor of consistent recurring revenue, even if, over time, the overall numbers are smaller, as long as they’re predictable.
When innovation is mentioned, it’s become a discussion of how to fit square AI pegs into round business goal holes, and just assuming revenue will go up as more people adopt AI universally.
Go-to-market is becoming another methodology unto itself, with flywheels imagined as perpetual motion machines, product-market fit sought for an ever-expanding collection of unnecessary features, and target audiences the size of a broad side of a barn. All of this leads to a lack of mechanics to, you know, narrowly define the target market, properly fit it, and spin the flywheel until you get traction.
This kind of thinking ultimately led to an unfortunate but inevitable outcome.
Product got kneecapped in the great tech RIF
I don’t know this first-hand, but anecdotally, based on who I’m hearing from, if software developers got slapped around hard in the mass layoffs of 2023 and 2024, “product people” got just plain decimated.
Here’s why.
Executives can make a case that AI can replace human ingenuity for tasks like developing a roadmap and sticking to it, hitting and maintaining consistent recurring revenue targets, and finding increasingly efficient and cost-effective ways to reach deeper into ever-broadening markets.
If you were a “product person” sitting in front of Jira and Confluence and spreadsheets all day, you likely felt the ax, or at least the rush of air as it came down.
Product is not dead yet
As usual, I threw some confusing (clickbaity) histrionics in the title. I’m not saying product management is dead. Yet. I’m just saying this is how it’s going to happen and it would indeed be untimely. Because if we’re going to get out of tech’s current malaise, it’s going to take the risk tolerance for innovation, the spirit of entrepreneurship, and knowing what the people want and how to bring it to them.
That’s what I told my friend. This didn’t put her off, in fact, it fired her up. Because on its face, this might not be so much a demise as it is a reset, just like I believe it is in software development.
See, when AI produces the same product built on the same code for the same target market – and does that over and over again enough times, well, now you need someone to come in and innovate your way out of that death loop.
Real “product people” are going to be just as critical as real “software developers.”
So now that we’ve crash-landed back on the bottom floor, it’s probably a pretty good time to get in. Maybe you’d like to ride along with me.
EXPERT OPINION BY JOE PROCOPIO, FOUNDER, TEACHINGSTARTUP.COM @JPROCO
Thursday, October 24, 2024
This Expert Says AI Efficiency Soars When It Uses Video to Crunch Numbers
The newest feature of the smartest AI systems is called multimodality, a fancy term that means AIs can respond to prompts besides typed text. You can combine a query like “make up a logo for my fab new vintage furniture refurbishment company” with an image of your favorite shade of yellow, and a shell or other inspirational picture, for example. AI researcher Simon Willison recently found a clever way to use this capability to solve a tedious math problem. The way he did it shines a light on how we may use AI chatbots differently in the near future.
Willison was working on one of those everyday accounting tasks that sounds simple but inevitably ends up being time-consuming. He wanted to tally all the charges he’d incurred for using a cloud company’s services. But, as news site ArsTechnica notes, Willison’s data was embedded all over the place in lots of different emails and so on, so finding it all and manually extracting the info would be one of those soul-destroying office jobs.
Then inspiration struck. Willison turned on his computer’s “screen recording” system, which creates a video of everything you do on the desktop, and then he navigated between all the different emails and sources of the numbers he needed, simply scrolling past the right data along with all the other info in each message. Then he put that video into Google’s AI Studio system, which, as Ars explains, lets users try out “several versions of Google’s Gemini 1.5 Pro and Gemini 1.5 Flash AI mode” AI systems. Willison prompted the AI to look at the video, telling it to pull out any relevant numbers it could see, and then put them in a specially formatted file that could be easily loaded into a spreadsheet, including specific information like dates and exact price amounts.
The task took moments, was effectively free because of the experimental nature of AI Studio, and apparently delivered accurate data that Willison was able to verify—saving him a lot of time.
So far, so very nerdy. But why should you care about this feat, other than admiring Willison’s lateral thinking?
Because by screen recording like this, Willison noted that there’s no real limit to where the data you’re prompting an AI comes from. There’s “no level of website authentication or anti-scraping technology that can stop me from recording a video of my screen while I manually click around inside a web application,” he noted in a blog, meaning any user could record their scrolling through a website, flicking pages in a complex Excel sheet or even scanning proprietary company emails.
This may soon be how we all use AIs in our work and with other tasks. When OpenAI revealed its next-gen ChatGPT model in May, it showed how its computer apps could “watch” what users are doing on screen, acting in a kind of angel-on-your-shoulder role. You could then ask the AI to process what it had seen, without going through the tedious task of typing in lots of words or numbers—similar to Willison’s screen recording. In an office, this means you could get AI help with, say, a complex financial analysis of your company’s revenue data merely by showing it to the AI.
There’s an inherent security risk here, obviously: data uploaded to an AI may be used to train its algorithms, and lead to sensitive info “leaking” from the AI to other users later on. Microsoft’s slightly similar, slightly more eerie, AI Recall feature sparked controversy and criticism this summer for similar reasons.
But AI systems like this are on the way, and are being threaded ever deeper into our work PCs and smartphones. OpenAI, for example, just revealed its PC ChatGPT app, which will likely be able to do the “watching your screen” trick. And Apple is preparing to release the first integration of ChatGPT into its famous Siri chatbot.
All of this is a reminder that learning how to use AIs is not a one-and-done task: You’ll need to keep training your staff to stay up to date on the latest tricks. And you’ll also have to keep reminding them to be wary of showing an AI the wrong kind of sensitive company data.
BY KIT EATON @KITEATON
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)